Question:
do plants have feelings ?
chris
2007-06-07 06:56:46 UTC
if they vdo what kind
Eleven answers:
Sci Fi Insomniac
2007-06-07 07:02:48 UTC
They don't have a central nervous system. That means no brain, no real feelings that we can relate to.

But - who knows? We can't tell what other humans are feeling, let alone if animals or plants are feeling. Some people are accused of anthropomorphizing animals, especially pets (I don't agree).

So it's all hypothetical until we figure out how to delve into the inner workings of minds - then we'll try and get to plants.
mikecraig11
2007-06-07 16:54:11 UTC
They feel.

If you examine a tree and the bark, etc, and then take an axe and start chopping away at a tree, and then examine the tree again, you will notice that the tree has released sap and other agents to try and protect itself against the damage.

Also, amazingly, some tree and other plant species are able to send chemical messages to other individuals of their same species to "warn" them that danger is coming.





A little music trivia: the Seattle grunge band "The Screaming Trees" were named based on this idea.
J_wind
2007-06-07 14:06:43 UTC
It is very possible that plants have sensitivities that we do not yet understand. Because plants do not have nervous systems and cannot run away from predators, it has generally been assumed that they do not experience pain and suffering. Recent scientific evidence suggests that this assumption may be incorrect. However, we do know that birds and other nonhuman vertebrates have well-developed nervous systems and pain receptors the same as humans. Like us, they show pleasure and pain and they present comparable evidence of fear and well-being. Animals cry out in pain, they nurse wounded body parts, and they seek to avoid those who have hurt them in the past.



In order to live, one has to eat. However, when we eat animal products, we consume many more plants indirectly than if we ate those plants directly, because the animals we eat are fed huge quantities of grasses, grains, and seeds to be converted into meat, milk, and eggs. As a vegan (one who eats no animal products) you cause fewer beings to suffer and die for you.



2. What will we do with all the animals if we stop eating them? Won't they overrun the earth?



Farm animals will not overrun the earth if we stop eating them because we will no longer intentionally breed them as we do now. Parent flocks and herds are deliberately maintained by artificial insemination, genetic selection, bizarre lighting schedules and other manipulations to force them to produce billions of offspring each year. This inflated population will fade as people stop eating animal products. In time, as David Gabbe states in Why Do Vegetarians Eat Like That?, "farm animals could be left to fend for themselves; some would make out fine, others would struggle to keep from becoming extinct. But, like all animals (except humans), they would adjust their numbers in accordance with the conditions around them."



In the meantime, we have to remember that we, not they, are responsible for their predicament. We have an obligation to find ways to ease the transitional period for these animals.
curie.genius
2007-06-07 14:59:33 UTC
If u make a cut on the plant then it heals it up then that probably means that they realise that they know some part has been damaged.

They might be feeling the pain maybe or maybe not.

Probably, they can feel hott and cold environmental changes because they adapt themselves to these conditions.

However, I don't think they have emotional feelings.
shipdada
2007-06-07 14:16:30 UTC
Yes they do, you won't believe but modern science proved that plants and tress also talk and cry but the sound decibels they create is beyond the audibility to human ears that's why we cant hear anything. Human ear's audibility limit is between 20 Hz and 20KHz.

There is more to it in detail but this is a simple description to your answer.
>wonder whats next<
2007-06-07 14:05:50 UTC
the have some kind of telepathic feelings, they did some kind of experiment on this on mythbusters, they hooked up some kind of machine to the plant to view electrical activity, and they had someone stand in the room with the plant and think a negative thought towards it, and they was a clear reaction on the machine, so i would say, yes, they have some kind of feelings
Ms Ghost
2007-06-07 14:10:23 UTC
No, they don't exactly have "feelings" like we do, speaking in terms of "science".



I'm not science expert but when I was little, I treat plants and even inanimate objects as though they do have feelings. Feelings like sadness, happiness... and even pain.



I remember there's this one time when I was about the age of six or seven, I "adopted" a "pet" rock... LoL.



I love your question!
m
2007-06-07 14:19:43 UTC
yes plants have feelings , but we don't know how , I can give you some examples , the first is sunflower that feel the sun rays and turns towards it , second the plants that eats insects , they feel the touch of the insects and close upon them and devour them , and may be there are some other examples that I don't know .
mc23571
2007-06-07 14:03:42 UTC
As they lack of neurological system, supposedly they do not feel, however, they respond to environment changes and try to adapt or perish in a natural way.
anonymous
2007-06-07 13:59:56 UTC
playing music for them seems to help
morena60_2000
2007-06-07 14:00:05 UTC
idiot


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...